I Wanted a Definition of Behavior, Pronto. I Got a Three-Year Education Instead.

By Cheyanne Scharbatke-Church, Executive Director, Besa Global

Ever had an idea you figured would take a couple of hours, only to find yourself still working on it years later? Defining what counts as a behavior for social norms change has been that experience for me.
Here is the story…why it took so long and what ultimately came of it. Or if you like to read the last page first, here you go: Speaking the Language of Behavior — the third chapter in Besa Global’s Integrating Social Norms into Anti-Corruption and Accountability Programming Learning Series.
My ‘little’ idea was sparked over three years ago when working with a great group in Nigeria. We were trying to determine if adding a social norms lens to their programming would be valuable. The first step was to figure out what corrupt pattern of behavior the group wanted to change. Why? Because norms drive habitual behaviors. If a norm is present, the behavior won’t be one-off or random: these acts will be typical in that situation. And being typical doesn’t mean the behavior is frequent or happening all the time — rather when this situation arises this behavior is the ‘typical’ response.

We put this question first on the agenda, assuming it would take five, maybe ten, minutes. I opened the discussion by asking something like, "if your project was totally successful, what would that look like?". They answered that the corruption would be gone. Realizing that my question wasn't specific enough (my bad) I followed up with, "what would people be doing differently?". They earnestly responded, “They wouldn't be acting corruptly”.
While this answer is undoubtedly accurate, it does not provide us with a specific understanding of the habitual behavior we are trying to change. And that is the prerequisite for a social norms diagnostic, especially when it comes to abuses of entrusted power for personal gain.
Corruption encompasses a huge variety of different behaviors with everything from a powerful person calling a judge to influence his verdict, to altering procurement documents to favor a particular vendor. Different behaviors are driven by different norms which require different strategies for change.
"We learned — the hard way — that getting it wrong on the behavior blows up the social norm identification process."
Over the next year or so, we worked with numerous committed, dynamic, experienced organizations working in accountable governance and repeatedly ran into the same challenge — teams could not answer the question: what behavior is your policy or program trying to change? Some gave ‘typology-type answers’ by saying embezzlement or trading in influence or sexual corruption, yet even this level of specificity wasn't sufficient for a social norms-informed behavior change approach.
No problem, I’ll just whip up a quick cheat sheet…
Given the explosion in behavioral science approaches and literature over the past few years, I assumed that a quick review of key behavior change literature would deliver me a clear definition, pronto. I could then compile a one-pager cheat sheet tailored to the accountable governance world.
What’s the opposite of pronto?
And I was right; the literature did define behavior: it is ‘an act’ or ‘something people do’. Clear, easy, and on the surface, it seemed like an answer to my question. The problem was when I tried to operationalize this definition in the context of accountable governance, it didn’t provide functional boundaries.
Specifically, when it comes to the abuse of entrusted power for personal gain what counts as an act? Is it sufficient to say patients pay bribes for faster service in the hospital? Or does the actual way the act is conducted matter? Is giving a gift after the care is provided the same behavior as slipping an envelope to the charge nurse upfront? Both are exchanges of assets for service—they just differ in timing and asset type. And corruption is a team sport – so can we define the act as the transaction or does every transaction have at least two behaviors – one for each person involved?
This matters: we learned — the hard way — that getting it wrong on the behavior blows up the social norm identification process.
Yet the literature offered us little more to go on. Though it did raise some important questions about whether drawing behavior change lessons from other fields is appropriate for accountable governance. My fall down that rabbit hole can be read here: The Differences That Make a Difference in Behaviors although our blog stats tell me that readers weren’t half as interested as I was 😊.
Still needing to make this concept practical and clear, I reached out to several experienced practitioners to mine their expertise. We even convened a discussion on what counts as a behavior with the (now defunct) USAID behavior change community of practice. These were engaging, rich conversations that typically ended with two conclusions:
the more specific the articulation of the behavior the better, and;
the behavioral science field hasn't put out anything that explicitly articulates functional boundaries of what constitutes a behavior.
So the cheat sheet expanded into a guidance note to address the complexities of applying behavior to the accountable governance domain. We used this three-pager with our partners at the time — government and civil society program teams.
How a guidance note became Chapter 3: Speaking the Language of Behavior
The trouble was once we gave teams the guidance note, they asked questions. And they were excellent questions, like:
What about who is doing the act — does that matter?
Our take: A behavior is not a behavior without an actor. Think of behaviors as who does what.
Does it matter if the behavior is corrupt or not corrupt when figuring out what is the habitual behavior?
Our take: In terms of getting as specific as possible in describing the behavior, no, it doesn’t matter. But in terms of identifying the social norm and designing programs it absolutely does.
What about the acts involved with implementing anti-corruption work—aren't they behaviors as well?
Our take: Well, yes they are! We have a whole workstream around behaviors that block the implementation of anti-corruption work, but are not corrupt themselves. An extraordinarily important type of behavior to pay attention to in our field.
And with this my guidance note became a full-blown chapter: Speaking the Language of Behavior. It defines behavior as “what people do”, offers the lessons we have learned (so far) on how to make that definition functional (including answering the questions above), and then provides the reader with a whole whack of examples.
This chapter has been through more drafts than almost any of our other work. It is the collective product of tens of people’s experience, input, and time. Thank you to everyone who knowingly or unknowingly participated in its evolution.
Are you fluent in the language of behavior? Check it out and let us know your thoughts.

Cheyanne Scharbatke-Church is a practitioner-scholar with a lifelong interest in governance processes that have run amok. She has significant experience in peacebuilding, governance, anti-corruption, evaluation and learning across the Balkans, West and East Africa. She currently serves as the Executive Director of Besa Global, where she also co-leads the Corruption, Justice & Legitimacy (CJL) Program. In this capacity she has pioneered the application of systems thinking to corruption analysis and the role of social norms as a driver of corrupt practices. Cheyanne taught on the intersection of conflict and corruption as well as program design, monitoring and evaluation in fragile contexts at the Fletcher School, Tufts University for 15 years. Prior to this, as the first Director of Evaluation for Search for Common Ground she developed the organization’s initial strategy to institutionalize an evidence and learning culture and practice. Her interest in understanding peacebuilding effectiveness started during her role as the Director of Policy & Evaluation at INCORE, University of Ulster. She has had the privilege of working in an advisory capacity with a range of organizations such as ABA/ROLI, CDA, ICRC, IDRC, UN Peacebuilding Fund and the US State Department. She can be commonly found in the Canadian Rockies with her fierce daughters and gem of a husband.





